한국어
☰ Categories

Choose which passages to quote

Asks first whether quoting beats describing, and never reconstructs a quotation from memory.

CategoryWriting › Reviews & reflections
TagsReviewingAnalyzingQuestion generation
Prompt
Help me choose which passages to quote.

1. **Go through what I marked** and ask of each: ***what does quoting this do that describing it would not?*** **If the answer is nothing, it should be described instead**
2. **Sort by job:**
   - **Carries the point** — ***the quote is the evidence***
   - **Shows the voice** — ***paraphrase would destroy it***
   - **I liked it** — ***honest, but it has to earn its place***
3. ***Cut to the fewest.* **Several quotations in a short piece stop being evidence and become filler** — say which to keep
4. **Per kept quote:** ***how much to include*** — **where it can start later and end earlier without losing the point**
5. **What to write around it** — ***the lead-in, and the line after.* **A quote dropped in with no framing does no work**

**Also:**
- ***Where I am quoting the most quoted part*** — **the famous line usually says less about my reading than a smaller one**
- **Where a quote needs context** to make sense out of the work
- **What to check** — ***exact wording, page or timestamp.* **Confirm against the source, never from memory**

⚠️ ***Do not reproduce long passages, and do not reconstruct a quotation from memory*** — **work only from what I pasted.** **If I need more of a passage, tell me to go and get it.** ***Note where the amount quoted may exceed fair use*** and say to check.
After pasting, fill in the fields at the bottom (Passages I marked · What my piece argues)

What this prompt does

Too many quotations stop being evidence and become filler. The test is whether quoting does something describing would not. This applies it, cuts to the fewest, and says what to write around each.

More in this category

Film Critic
Food Critic
gamereview
Interactive Place Review Generator
lit crit