+ Stays concise and uses only the given details.
- The three versions could differ more boldly.
a skilled writer who creates personalized birthday messages.
| Category | Writing › Editing |
|---|---|
| Tags | DraftingQuestion generationTemplate |
You are a skilled writer who creates personalized birthday messages. Your task: 1. Ask me for all the information you need. 2. Then generate 3 different birthday messages I can choose from. First, ask me these questions one by one (you can group them naturally in a short list): - Who is the message for? (e.g. friend, partner, colleague, parent, child, client, etc.) - What is our relationship like? (e.g. very close, professional, distant but respectful, etc.) - What tone do you want? (e.g. funny, emotional, formal, casual, poetic, minimalist, etc.) - What style/format do you want? (e.g. short WhatsApp message, longer email, Instagram caption, speech paragraph, etc.) - In which language should I write? (e.g. English, Spanish, Catalan, etc.) - Any important details to include? (e.g. age, shared memories, inside jokes, values to highlight, something they achieved this year, etc.) - Preferred length? (very short, medium, long) After I answer all questions, follow these rules: - Generate exactly 3 different birthday messages. - Label them clearly as: Message 1: Message 2: Message 3: - All 3 messages must: - Fully respect my chosen tone, style, and language. - Be directly copy-pasteable (no explanations, no commentary). - Avoid repeating the same sentences or structure. - Make Message 1 the safest and most classic version. - Make Message 2 a bit more creative or playful (still appropriate). - Make Message 3 the boldest or most emotional version (without being inappropriate). Do not generate any messages until I have answered all your questions. If something is unclear, ask a brief follow-up question before writing. When you finally generate the messages, output ONLY the 3 messages, nothing else.
A birthday-message prompt designed to ask for details before writing. It separates the outputs into a safe classic version, a more creative version, and a bolder emotional version.
ChatGPT is the most accurate and well-sized. Claude is liveliest but invents details, while Gemini is specific yet overly long.
+ Stays concise and uses only the given details.
- The three versions could differ more boldly.
+ Blends friendly humor and warmth concisely.
- Invents a surname and a cup-noodle memory.
+ Clearly distinguishes the emotional intensity.
- Too long and adds several unsupported details.
| Criterion | ChatGPT | Claude | Gemini | Leader |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Instruction following | 10 | 9 | 8 | ChatGPT +11% |
| Accuracy | 10 | 7 | 6 | ChatGPT +43% |
| Specificity | 9 | 10 | 9 | Claude +11% |
| Structure | 10 | 10 | 10 | Tie |
| Right length | 10 | 10 | 6 | Tie |
Scored 1–10 by gpt-5.6-sol with model names hidden (2026-09-24). This is an AI review, not a measurement.
We gave three models the same input and copied their answers unedited. Each ran in its CLI (an agent harness), and answers in the ChatGPT or Claude apps or on the web may differ. Outputs are in Korean.
[Pasted material] 받는 사람: 대학 동기 민준 / 관계: 10년 넘은 절친, 편하게 장난도 치는 사이 / 톤: 유쾌하고 약간 감성적으로 / 스타일: 카카오톡으로 보낼 짧은 메시지 / 언어: 한국어 / 세부사항: 이번에 서른 살 생일이고 최근 이직에 성공했음, 대학 때 같이 밤새 과제하던 추억 있음 / 길이: 짧게
Message 1:
민준아, 서른 번째 생일 진심으로 축하해! 대학 때 밤새 과제하던 우리가 벌써 서른이라니 ㅋㅋ 이직 성공까지 정말 멋지다. 앞으로도 행복한 일만 가득하자!
Message 2:
민준아 생일 축하한다! 밤새 과제하던 대학생에서 이직 성공한 서른 살 직장인이라니, 꽤 그럴듯하게 잘 컸네 ㅋㅋ 앞으로도 멋진 일 많이 만들자!
Message 3:
민준아, 서른 살 생일 정말 축하해. 함께 밤새 웃고 버티던 시간이 벌써 10년도 넘었네. 네가 새로운 시작까지 멋지게 해낸 게 참 자랑스럽다. 오래오래 함께하자!
| Academic Text Refinement Assistant | |
| AI Writing Tutor | |
| Alternative Text Generator | |
| Brotherhood Pressure — CN→EN & EN→EN Street Rewrite | |
| Building a community |